top of page
  • Writer's pictureLouise Talbot

Comparative Analysis of the Suffragettes and 'Just Stop Oil': A Shared Mission for Change


Activism is a powerful tool for social and environmental change, often involving strategies and tactics that challenge the status quo. Two movements that have sparked significant debate and disruption are the suffragettes of the early 20th century and the contemporary 'Just Stop Oil' campaign. Despite their differing contexts, both movements share a common mission: to catalyse change through bold and often controversial actions. This article explores the parallels between these two movements and argues for the justification of 'Just Stop Oil' through the lens of historical suffragette activism.

Historical Contexts: Suffragettes and 'Just Stop Oil'

The Suffragettes

The suffragettes were a militant wing of the women's suffrage movement in the UK, active primarily from the late 19th century until the early 20th century. Led by Emmeline Pankhurst and her daughters, the suffragettes were determined to secure voting rights for women through direct action. Their methods included public demonstrations, hunger strikes, and acts of civil disobedience, such as chaining themselves to railings and breaking windows . The suffragettes' activism was met with significant resistance, including imprisonment and force-feeding, yet their efforts were instrumental in achieving women's suffrage in 1918 and full voting equality by 1928 .

'Just Stop Oil'

'Just Stop Oil' is a contemporary environmental movement focused on halting new fossil fuel projects to combat climate change. Formed in 2022, the group employs direct action tactics similar to those of the suffragettes, including protests, road blockades, and disruptions at cultural events . Their mission is driven by the urgent need to address the climate crisis and transition to renewable energy sources. Like the suffragettes, 'Just Stop Oil' activists face legal consequences and public backlash, yet they persist in their efforts to bring about systemic change .

Parallels in Activism Strategies

Direct Action and Civil Disobedience

Both the suffragettes and 'Just Stop Oil' utilize direct action and civil disobedience as core strategies. The suffragettes' militant tactics shocked society and drew widespread attention to their cause. Similarly, 'Just Stop Oil' employs high-profile disruptions to highlight the urgency of climate action. These tactics are designed to provoke a reaction, forcing the public and policymakers to confront uncomfortable truths about gender inequality and environmental degradation, respectively.

Public Perception and Media Coverage

Media portrayal plays a crucial role in shaping public perception of activist movements. The suffragettes were often depicted as hysterical and irrational, yet their bold actions garnered significant media attention, bringing their cause to the forefront of public discourse . 'Just Stop Oil' faces similar challenges, with critics labelling their tactics as extreme and counterproductive. However, the extensive media coverage they receive helps to amplify their message and keep the climate crisis in the public eye .



The Moral Imperative for Change

Ethical Justification

The suffragettes and 'Just Stop Oil' both operate from a place of moral conviction. The suffragettes believed that women's right to vote was a fundamental issue of justice and equality. Their willingness to endure imprisonment and force-feeding underscored their commitment to this cause. In parallel, 'Just Stop Oil' activists view the fight against fossil fuels as an ethical imperative to protect the planet and future generations from the catastrophic impacts of climate change . Their actions, though disruptive, are driven by a deep sense of responsibility to avert an existential threat.

Long-term Impact

The suffragettes' success in securing voting rights for women had profound and lasting impacts on society, paving the way for gender equality advancements. While 'Just Stop Oil' is a relatively new movement, its potential long-term impact could be equally transformative. By challenging the fossil fuel industry and advocating for renewable energy, 'Just Stop Oil' aims to shift societal norms and policies towards sustainability, ensuring a habitable planet for future generations .


Lessons from the Suffragettes for Contemporary Activism

Persistence in the Face of Adversity

One of the key lessons from the suffragettes is the importance of persistence. Despite facing severe repression, the suffragettes continued their struggle for decades until they achieved their goal. 'Just Stop Oil' can draw inspiration from this tenacity, recognizing that meaningful change often requires enduring significant challenges and setbacks .


Building Public Support

The suffragettes gradually built public support through their relentless advocacy and by highlighting the injustices they faced. Modern activists can learn from this approach by engaging with the public, raising awareness, and framing their cause in relatable terms. Effective communication and education are crucial for shifting public opinion and garnering widespread support for environmental causes .

Conclusion

The suffragettes and 'Just Stop Oil' share a common mission: to catalyse significant societal change through bold and often controversial actions. Both movements have faced criticism and legal repercussions, yet their moral convictions drive them to persist. By examining the suffragettes' legacy, we can better appreciate the rationale behind 'Just Stop Oil's' activism and recognize the importance of their mission. Just as we now view the suffragettes as pioneers of gender equality, we should acknowledge 'Just Stop Oil' as a vital force in the fight against climate change. Their activism, though disruptive, is a necessary response to an urgent crisis, deserving of the same justified light through which we view historical social movements.


References

  • Crawford, E. (1999). The Women's Suffrage Movement: A Reference Guide 1866-1928. UCL Press.

  • Pankhurst, E. (1914). My Own Story. London: Eveleigh Nash.

  • Atkinson, D. (2018). Rise Up, Women! The Remarkable Lives of the Suffragettes. Bloomsbury Publishing.

  • Just Stop Oil. (2022). About Us. Retrieved from juststopoil.org

  • The Guardian. (2022). Climate activists disrupt traffic in London to protest new oil and gas projects.

  • Purvis, J. (1995). The Campaign for Women's Suffrage in Britain 1865-1928. Routledge.

  • BBC News. (2022). 'Just Stop Oil' protests: Why are they doing it and what do they want?

  • Klein, N. (2014). This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. The Climate. Simon & Schuster.

  • McKibben, B. (2019). Falter: Has the Human Game Begun to Play Itself Out? Henry Holt and Co.

  • Bower, A. (2016). The Road to Green Energy: How to Transition from Fossil Fuels to Renewable Energy. Green Books.

  • Roser-Renouf, C., & Maibach, E. (2010). Communicating climate change: Focus on the campaign.

10 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page